San Diego Criminal Lawyers Blog
In the latest of the terrifying bills that have come out of our current Congress, Republicans in the House and Senate recently introduced two companion bills they are calling the Back the Blue Act of 2017, to keep up with the Trump Administration’s rhetoric of “law and order.” S.1134 was introduced by John Cornyn (R-Tex.), and is co-sponsored by 15 senators, all Republicans. H.R.2437 as introduced by Ted Poe (R-Tex.), and includes five co-sponsors, also all Republicans.
What the Bills do
The bills would create a new category of federal crimes for killing or attempting to kill a state or local law enforcement officer who works for a police agency that receives federal funding. It in effect treats all local police agencies as federal agencies because nearly all police agencies already receive some sort of federal funding. The bill would also allow for the federal death penalty in such cases, and it would impose limits on the ability of defendants to file habeas petitions in federal court after they have exhausted their appeals.
The bill would also make it a federal crime to “assault” any police officer, bringing a federal mandatory prison sentence of two to 10 years.
Additionally, the bills would allow a district attorney to overrule local officials if he or she did not like the way those officials were handling a case involving a police death. As it stands, the language of the proposed legislation explicitly authorizes federal prosecutions in cases where “the verdict or sentence obtained pursuant to State charges left demonstratively un-vindicated the Federal interest in eradicating bias-motivated violence.”
Qualified Immunity
It has always been the case that police actions are covered under qualified immunity, which means that in order for a victim’s lawsuit to proceed, the plaintiff in a civil rights lawsuit must show that not only were his or her rights violated, but also that a reasonable police officer should have known that the actions in question were a violation of the Constitution (essentially that the police intentionally violated his or her rights).
Under the language of this proposed bill, police would only be liable for out-of-pocket expenses and not statutory punitive damages, such as in instances of Section 1983 lawsuits under the Civil Rights Act. Lastly, the bills would bar plaintiffs from recovering attorneys fees under Section 1988 of the Civil Rights Act.
The bills are being opposed by civil rights and accountability groups nation-wide.
Have You Suffered Prison Abuse and Police Brutality? We can Help
Excessive force and abuse by police is unacceptable. At the Law Offices of David M. Boertje, we understand the importance of keeping you out of jail and maintaining your right to be treated with dignity even while being detained or questioned. We will defend your constitutional rights and freedoms as well as file complaints on your behalf. We will work to ensure your rights through the booking process to charging, and throughout trial. If you have been charged with a crime or have had your constitutional rights violated by the police, do not hesitate to contact attorney David Boertje today.